Roofing defects can be prevented

As manager of the Roof Service department at BMI Monier, Jan van Leeuwen sees every day where things could be improved on the roof. He has been following developments closely for eighteen years. He sees two major problems, both caused primarily by time pressure and a lack of expertise: construction defects are still not declining, and the number of incorrectly installed PV panels on roofs is increasing.
A roof is an integrated system, not a collection of separate components
He sees a clear solution to both: use BIM to build the entire roofing system virtually in detail in advance, including any PV panels, and choose certified roofers with the expertise to install PV panels.
Using BIM prevents construction defects and boosts productivity
Over the past six months, Van Leeuwen and colleagues from other BMI Monier technical centres have created BIM models for all types of roof tiles. But it is not just the tiles: all system components, such as fixings, eaves profiles and roofing membrane, have also been modelled in BIM. This makes it possible to build the entire roofing system virtually, resolving any challenges in advance. This saves time during construction, prevents too much or the wrong material from being ordered, improves quality and avoids mistakes. In the long run, a roofing system modelled in BIM in advance is cheaper to build and comes with a full guarantee. According to Van Leeuwen, the increasingly common construction method of using prefabricated roof elements alongside a roofing system modelled in BIM is a fast and cost-effective way to deliver an excellent roof. Unfortunately, knowledge of BIM is still uneven across the construction industry. There is plenty of room for improvement, which would help reduce construction costs and increase productivity.

Widespread lack of expertise in PV panel installation
According to Van Leeuwen, PV panels are often installed incorrectly on roofs. Once the roof has been covered, the contractor or a PV installer comes along and fits the panels. This is often the last item on the project’s budget, so the cheapest option is chosen. This can mean that fixings are installed without knowledge of the roofing system, compromising its quality and leaving the PV panels insufficiently resistant to wind. The installation regularly fails to meet the applicable NEN 7250 standard. After an installation of this kind, in which they have not been involved, roofers will only guarantee half the roof: the section without PV panels. The poor quality of PV panel installation on roofs is also reflected in a recent study by TNO. Between 80 and 99% of roof fires are caused by the incorrect use of connectors. Combined with the use of combustible membrane, this makes the roof a major risk factor. According to Van Leeuwen, this clearly shows that the quality of installation on roofs is seriously inadequate. The TNO study also found that staff are selected more for their lack of fear of heights than for their installation expertise. Van Leeuwen sees another problem in the fact that when a PV system is installed separately on a roof, nobody has an overview of the whole. PV panels and the roofing system are treated as separate components, with all the consequences that entails.
PV panels included in BIM modelling
The BIM modules for roofs made available by BMI Monier also include PV panels and their fixing components. Based on the desired energy output, these can be used to determine in advance exactly where and how many PV panels should be installed on the roof, and how best to fix them. Having the complete system installed by one and the same approved party ensures that the warranty on the entire roofing system remains valid

Jan van Leeuwen
Sharing expertise improves the quality of the roofing system
The staff in BMI Monier’s Roof Service department have all the expertise needed to build a high-quality roofing system. This is partly because they think in terms of systems rather than individual components. A roof is a system, and that is why it is tested as a system at BMI Monier’s technical centres. The watertightness of every roofing system is thoroughly tested in the company’s own wind tunnels; its in-house developed fixings are tested under all kinds of loads; and membranes and other roofing system components are tested in its own laboratories to ensure the performance of the roofing systems. The tests use wind forces and freeze-thaw cycles that far exceed the standards applicable to the construction industry. Van Leeuwen and his colleagues share this expertise every day with architects, contractors and roofers. In addition, several staff members in the Roof Service department sit on various standards committees. This is how BMI Monier shares its expertise with as many parties as possible. With just one aim: to ensure that every roof is built with dedication and expertise.
Question about this story? Ask your question
Keep following this
Get an email when a new story is published. No account needed.
- SubjectGeneral


















