General

Is the CDA scuppering the privatisation of building control?

Is the CDA scuppering the privatisation of building control?

On 23 April 2019, the Senate considers the bill for the Quality Assurance (Building) Act, after which a vote will take place. This historic building law has attracted considerable attention following the terrible fire at Grenfell Tower in London and the collapse of the car park at Eindhoven Airport. Opponents of privatisation fear disasters like those in England, where building control is carried out by private bodies. Supporters of privatisation believe that municipal building control failed in Eindhoven.

Status of the Quality Assurance (Building) Act bill

Plans to privatise building control were drawn up more than twenty years ago. The House of Representatives passed the bill by a large majority. At the request of former PvdA minister Plasterk, however, the Senate postponed the vote on 11 July 2017. The CDA has reservations about the PvdA amendments, and without the CDA there is no majority in the Senate. After 658 days, the bill is back for a vote, now with D66 minister Ollongren at the helm. The question is whether the CDA will vote down the bill, which was drawn up by coalition partner VVD.

The quality assurance system

The key point is that the bill does not change the municipality’s enforcement powers. Building control officers can inspect work during construction and take enforcement action if necessary.

During a debate with the House of Representatives on 6 December 2018, Ollongren said: ‘It is not accurate to frame this as the privatisation of building control.’ However, the main responsibility for inspecting construction work will rest with a new private quality assurance assessor. That certainly suggests privatisation.

Is this private assessor marking their own homework?

No. The quality assurance assessor must be independent of the permit holder, architect and contractor. The assessor must declare whether the completed building complies with the technical building regulations. Without a positive declaration, the building may not be occupied.

Current municipal building control

Municipalities are not currently required to check that completed buildings comply with the technical building regulations. In practice, they often do not. Yet what matters is that the building itself is safe, not just the plans on paper.

At present, a municipality can grant an environmental permit (building permit) if it is merely plausible that the building plans on paper comply with the technical building regulations. After the permit has been granted, the permit holder can still submit calculations up to three weeks before construction begins.

The choice to improve quality

There is considerable fear of privatisation. It has a poor reputation in the Netherlands. However, various studies show that smaller municipalities lack the expertise and skills needed to ensure adequate building control.

Repeated attempts to improve building control have failed. Raising permit fees to hire more officers is not an option. The fees are already very high. Another possibility is to consolidate this work within environmental services, allowing officers to share their expertise and skills. However, under the Environment and Planning Act, which is due to come into force on 1 January 2021, building control is not part of the core duties of environmental services.

That leaves the quality assurance system as the remaining option. How can municipalities now hand over building control? The answer is simple: they will not. A municipal environmental permit is still required, and the municipality can still take enforcement action. The only change is that the municipality will no longer check compliance with the technical building regulations in advance. So, this is not privatisation. Municipalities will also receive the information they need to enforce the rules. The VNG has agreed this with minister Ollongren.

MOT test for buildings

A private inspection does not necessarily have to go wrong. Consider the MOT test carried out on cars by garages. A compulsory private final inspection is still better than no inspection at all.

Of course, municipalities could also carry out the final inspection, but unfortunately they do not have the necessary financial resources. Minister Ollongren is also opposed to a municipal final inspection, as this would place more responsibility on the municipalities. They neither designed nor built the building plans. It is therefore not primarily for the municipality to judge whether the building is safe. If a car crashes shortly after its MOT test because of defective brakes, the garage that carried out the test will be held responsible, at least in the public’s mind.

The bill also increases contractors’ liability and strengthens their duty to warn. Bouwend Nederland, among others, opposes this. More than half of construction defects originate in the design. Contractors must not end up being held responsible for them.

Now or never

Politicians want to improve building control to prevent accidents such as the one in Eindhoven. The honest answer is that if the Senate votes down the bill, nothing is likely to change for a long time. Minister Ollongren does not want to submit a revised bill to the House of Representatives to amend the original proposal. No alternative has the support of all parties in the construction sector. In addition, the construction lobby is very powerful. The bill now before the Senate is the compromise that has been reached. In any event, all eyes will soon be on the CDA.

Question about this story? Ask your question

Keep following this

Get an email when a new story is published. No account needed.

What you follow
  • SubjectGeneral
Share this article

Advertisement

Follow on Stedenbouw

Follow

Follow a project or company and you’ll receive an email whenever a new story appears. Follow a theme or topic and you’ll receive a weekly roundup. No account or password needed: every email includes a link to what you follow.